Write a Blog >>
ICST 2022
Mon 4 - Fri 8 April 2022
Wed 6 Apr 2022 19:45 - 20:00 at Margaret Hamilton - ICST Automated Testing 2 Chair(s): Jose Campos

Machine Learning (ML) algorithms are inherently random in nature – executing them using the same inputs may lead to slightly different results across different runs. Such randomness makes it challenging for developers to write tests for their implementations of ML algorithms. A natural consequence of randomness is test flakiness – tests both pass and fail non- deterministically for same version of code.

Developers often choose to alleviate test flakiness in ML projects by setting seeds in the random number generators used by the code under test. However, this approach only best serves as a “workaround”. Instead of fixing the test, it makes the test more brittle and can potentially cause developers to miss bugs which may be only triggered by a different sequence of computations.

We conduct the first large-scale empirical study of the usage of seeds and its implications on testing on a corpus of 114 Machine Learning projects. We identify 461 tests in these projects which fail without seeds and study their nature and root causes. We also try to minimize the flakiness of a subset of 42 identified tests using alternative strategies such as tuning algorithm hyper-parameters and adjusting assertion bounds and send them to developers. So far, developers have accepted our fixes for 19 tests.

We also manually analyze a subset of 56 tests and study various characteristics such as the nature of test oracles and how the seed settings evolve over time. Finally, we provide several important insights and their implications for both researchers and developers in the context of setting seeds in tests.

Wed 6 Apr

Displayed time zone: Amsterdam, Berlin, Bern, Rome, Stockholm, Vienna change

19:30 - 20:45
ICST Automated Testing 2Research Papers / Journal-First Papers at Margaret Hamilton
Chair(s): Jose Campos University of Lisbon, Portugal
19:30
15m
Talk
Providing Real-time Assistance for Repairing Runtime Exceptions using Stack Overflow Posts
Research Papers
Sonal Mahajan Uber Technologies Inc., Mukul Prasad Fujitsu Research of America
19:45
15m
Talk
To Seed or Not to Seed? An Empirical Analysis of Usage of Seeds for Testing in Machine Learning Projects
Research Papers
Saikat Dutta University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Anshul Arunachalam University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Sasa Misailovic University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
20:00
15m
Talk
Integration testing for robotic systems
Journal-First Papers
Maria Brito Federal University of Lavras Lavras, Simone do Rocio Senger de Souza ICMC/USP, Paulo Sergio Lopes de Souza ICMC/USP
Link to publication DOI
20:15
15m
Talk
Patterns of Code-to-Test Co-evolution for Automated Test Suite Maintenance
Research Papers
Samiha Shimmi Northern Illinois University, Mona Rahimi Northern Illinois University
20:30
15m
Live Q&A
Discussion and Q&A
Research Papers